Movie Summaries

Radio Shows




Dr. Macro's
Movie Scans

Privacy Statement Visitor Agreement

Joan Crawford




MGM, 1933.  Directed by Howard Hawks.  Camera:  Oliver T. Marsh.  With Joan Crawford, Gary Cooper, Robert Young, Franchot Tone, Roscoe Karns, Murray Kinnell.

Diana Boyce-Smith (Joan Crawford), a young English playgirl during World War I, is having an affair with Claude (Robert Young), who serves as a British naval officer with Diana's brother Ronnie (Franchot Tone).  Diana thinks she is enamored of Claude, but changes her mind when True Love comes along in the person of American aviator Bogard (Gary Cooper).  But Bogard goes off on a flying mission and is reported killed.  Whereupon the heartbroken but still resilient Diana resumes her relationship with Claude, without benefit of clergy.

Her chief confidant is her brother Ronnie, but he tends to side with Claude when inevitable difficulties arise between Diana and Claude, for Ronnie feels that Diana is not being completely honest and fair with Claude.

Then Bogard, who had been thought dead, turns up alive and well.  Bogard, Claude and Ronnie are thrown together and begin a friendly but barbed sea-versus-air rivalry.  Scoffing at the Navy, Bogard takes Claude and Ronnie for a daredevil sky-ride.  When they return safely, Ronnie challenges Bogard to accompany him to sea on Ronnie's motor launch, which is equipped with a single torpedo.  After they have seen some stiff ocean action, Bogard has been duly convinced that there is just as much excitement on the sea as in the air.

Claude is blinded in action, and as he and Ronnie know that Diana deeply loves Bogard, they decide that her happiness should not be jeopardized a second time when they hear that Bogard has offered to sacrifice his life on a suicide mission that involves sinking an enemy ship.   So Ronnie and the blind Claude go out to sea in their launch and sink the vessel before Bogard has had a chance to attack it from the air.  They lose their lives in the process.  Bogard returns unharmed to Diana, and though relieved to be reunited, their joy is tempered by the knowledge of the frightful sacrifice of loved ones that made it possible.

What was said about Today We Live:

New York Times (Mordaunt Hall)
Miss Crawford, although she never impresses one as being English, gives a steadfast and earnest portrayal...(The Picture) is vague and cumbersome...As a drama of the war it is not precisely convincing, for coincidences play an important part in its arrangement.  It is also anachronistic, particularly as regards the costumes worn by Joan Crawford.

New York Herald Tribune (Richard Watts, Jr.)
Visually, Today We Live is handsome, striking and genuinely dramatic, and that is not merely because Miss Crawford is photographed so beautifully.  The scenes of aerial warfare are enormously effective, but such scenes have been portrayed so frequently that they have become the commonplaces of the photoplay...Miss Crawford is properly effective in her role even if she doesn't seem like someone called Boyce-Smith.

Although William Faulkner is billed as the author of Today We Live, the picture is no devastating survey of the degeneracy of the New South, filled with murderous neurotics and pathological passions.  Instead, it is a lugubrious romance of the war, replete with clipped speeches, heroic sacrifices, self-effacing nobility and many cries of "stout fellow!"  As a matter of fact, it is only when one of the characters begins to play quaintly with a cockroach that you see any particular traces of the Faulkner influence at all.  For the rest of the time, the work seems more akin to Journey's End than to Sanctuary or Light in August and devotes most of its efforts to permitting Robert Young and Franchot Tone to destroy themselves gallantly so that Gary Cooper may henceforth live happily with Miss Joan Crawford.  It was my suspicion yesterday that their sacrifice was too great.

The Films of Joan Crawford
by Lawrence J. Quirk
The Citadel Press, 1968

Additional detailed information about this film is available from
the AFI Catalog of Feature Films at
AFI.com, or by clicking here.